EVALUATION OF TEACHING
Summary of Best Practices Related to
Student Evaluation of Instruction (SEI) Items
Updated 4/10/2002
Best practices for instructors
are summarized here in relation to each item of the Student Evaluation of
Instruction (SEI) at The Ohio State University. This page summarizes columns
1 & 4 of the Rationale for SEI ItemsComparisons to Recent Research
with Suggestions to Instructors.
ITEM
1: THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS COURSE WAS WELL ORGANIZED.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Have clear learning goals
for the course and communicate them to the students early and on a regular
basis. It helps if the goals are stated in terms of observable skills and
knowledge rather than generalities.
- Have a well-organized
syllabus showing major themes of the course, how they play out in the activities,
and the way you will evaluate student learning. Try to stick to key dates,
such as exams and paper deadlines.
- Use evaluation methods
(tests, papers, projects) that are closely tied to your overall goals for
the course.
- Use items that test what
is important, not what is easy to ask about.
- Periodically update the
students on where they are in progressing toward the course goals.
- A second type of organization
is the organization of the content. Help students understand the underlying
structure of the course content and how it fits together and relates to other
courses. Draw a map or chart showing the organization of the content.
- Prepare for each class
period so that you have a clear idea of what is supposed to happen. Put an
outline of the agenda on the board at the beginning of class. Keep in mind
that no matter how organized you are, it does not help unless you communicate
it to your students.
ITEM 2:
THIS COURSE WAS INTELLECTUALLY STIMULATING.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
Know your students:
- During the first class
period, give students a pre-test to assess their existing knowledge about
the course content. This will help the instructor choose or revise the topics
and materials to be covered. This assessment can be done over many years to
obtain the profiles of the students who will be enrolled and to be aware of
changing trends in their profiles.
- Encourage students to
read or study materials other than textbooks or class handouts and to share
this with the instructor and peers.
- Assign homework which
encourages critical thinking and some research, rather than homework for which
students can easily find factual answers from the textbook.
- Explicitly address relevance
of course subject matter.
- Use vivid, familiar examples
to help students anchor concepts in their memory.
- Engage students in active
learning strategies that require them to think in more depth about the material
being presented. Discussions, debates, group work, and projects are just a
few ways.
ITEM 3:
THE INSTRUCTOR WAS GENUINELY INTERESTED IN TEACHING.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Explicitly address relevance.
- Tell students that you
care that they learn; remind them of your office hours, e-mail, etc.
For
the Teven and McCrosky findings on caring:
- Demonstrate your enthusiasm
for the subject matter.
- Discuss the learning
and teaching process explicitly.
- Track student progress
through the subject matter and discuss this progress in class (e.g., summarizing
topics covered, pointing out skills and knowledge that students have gained
so far in the course).
ITEM 4:
THE INSTRUCTOR ENCOURAGED STUDENTS TO THINK FOR THEMSELVES.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
See ITEM 2 above.
Active learning methods
such as problem solving, writing, and explicit teaching of critical thinking
reinforce these goals. [Note that Leeds (1997) disputes this finding, while
Byer (1997) supports it.]
ITEM 5:
THE INSTRUCTOR WAS WELL PREPARED.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Provide an outline of
what you expect to cover during a session.
- Try to use multiple modes
of delivery.
- Prepare necessary handouts.
- Anticipate questions
and be prepared for them.
- Make the transition from
topic to topic smooth. Use appropriate transition expressions. Check comprehension
between the transitions.
- Control time allocation
for each activity.
ITEM 6:
THE INSTRUCTOR WAS GENUINELY INTERESTED IN HELPING STUDENTS.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Good communication means
being aware of student understanding. Ways to monitor understanding include
watching student reactions and note-taking patterns, interjecting questions
or activities that require students to respond using the materials being presented,
inviting student questions, and acknowledging when material difficulty varies
significantly.
- Make the effort to include
activities in the class session that will give you feedback on how well students
are grasping what is being taught. Communicate to the students that you are
aware of that understanding by building your class sessions on their responses.
- Come to class a little
early or stay a little longer to interact with students and invite questions.
- Learn your students'
names and note how they are doing as you grade papers or tests.
- When a student makes
a mistake in class, don't over-react. Instead use it as an opportunity to
guide some further learning by helping the students and you understand where
the miscommunication came from.
For McCroskey's
findings that a sense of caring
comes from
empathy, understanding, and responsiveness:
Nurture a sense of caring
by being empathetic, understanding, and responsive: come to class early to
talk to students and answer questions, invite students to office hours, know
their names, share relevant information about your own experiences and interests.
ITEM
7: I LEARNED A GREAT DEAL FROM THIS INSTRUCTOR.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Give students assignments
that can reinforce learning and help them apply the knowledge to other or
real-life situations.
- Give students regular,
accurate, constructive feedback about their learning. Help them to see their
own achievements and what they need to do to achieve more.
For Teven
& McCroskey's findings that students report that
they learned more in courses in which the instructor was seen as caring:
Nurture
a sense of caring by being empathetic, understanding, and responsive: come
to class early to talk to students and answer questions, invite students to
office hours, know their names, share relevant information about your own
experiences and interests.
ITEM 8:
THE INSTRUCTOR CREATED AN ATMOSPHERE CONDUCIVE TO LEARNING.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Be open and interested
in what your students are saying and asking by making eye contact, actively
responding to their comments, not interrupting them in mid-comment, and using
all the other courtesies that you would accord to another adult.
- When responding to student
comments and questions, respond in a way that will not discourage future comments
from this student or others. Agree to the extent you can, explore the basis
for difference when you can't and build on their ideas.
- When you don't know an
answer, say so and then model how you would go about thinking about the question
in order to estimate or discover an answer.
- Engage students in active
learning strategies that require them to think in more depth about the material
being presented.
- Use activities in class
as a way of preparing for exam questions.
- If you are teaching a
controversial topic, have the class discuss the guidelines for handling disagreements
and discomfort that might arise during the discussion.
- Praise the student, not
necessarily the answer.
For Teven
and McCroskey's finding that students report that they are more likely
to take another course from that instructor and that they learned more in the
course:
Nurture
a sense of caring by being empathetic, understanding, and responsive: come
to class early to talk to students and answer questions, invite students to
office hours, know their names, share relevant information about your own
experiences and interests.
ITEM 9:
THE INSTRUCTOR COMMUNICATED THE SUBJECT MATTER CLEARLY.
What an
instructor can do in this area:
- Include good, clear concrete
examples with which students can identify supports communication. Inviting
students to give examples is also helpful.
- Don't avoid the important
technical language of your field when appropriate. Just be sure to teach it
to your students; don't assume that they know it.
- Lectures are enhanced
when the lecturer provides an outline of the presentation throughout the session
so students can see where they are in the overall scheme of things. Refer
to the outline as you move between topics.
- Clearly signal the type
of information you are presenting: is it a key concept or just an elaboration?
Are you still in the same topic area or are you about to move on? Use relational
transition words to cue student attention and understanding of relationships.
- A key to clear communication
in a lecture setting is finding the right density of information to use. Things
that increase information density are technical terms, rapid presentation,
abstractions with no examples, overcrowded visuals. Things that reduce density
are concrete examples familiar to the students, redundant sources of information,
repetition, pausing to allow for note-taking.
- Vary your voice, position,
demeanor, use of visuals, and other communication components to add interest.
- Be interested in your
topic, your teaching, and your students, and let your interest come through
in your voice and expression.
ITEM 10:
OVERALL, I WOULD RATE THIS INSTRUCTOR AS...
What an
instructor can do in this area:
(Among four areas [Items
1, 5, 7, 9], focus on the factor that you received the lowest score in.)
- Have clear learning goals
for the course and a well-organized syllabus.
- Organize the content
and present the organization to students using a map or chart.
- Put an outline of the
agenda on the board at the beginning of the class.
- Try to multiple modes
of delivery of the content.
- Prepare necessary handouts.
- Control time allocation
for each activity.
- Design activities for
which students can apply the knowledge obtained in the class to other or real-life
situations.
- Give students regular,
constructive feedback about their progress.
- Use relational transition
words to cue student attention and understanding of relationships.
- Find the right density
of information to use.
- Use good, clear, concrete
examples.
- Vary your voice, position,
demeanor, use of visuals, and other communication components.
To view the entire Rationale
for SEI ItemsComparisons to Recent Research with Suggestions to Instructors,
choose one of the following formats:
Narrative
formatHTML
Table
formatHTML
Table
formatPDF
Works
Cited